Wittgenstein on Other Minds
Strangers in a Strange Land
By Constantine Sandis
Other Formats Available:
E-Book- About This Book
- Reviews
- Author Information
- Series
- Table of Contents
- Links
- Podcasts
About This Book
Constantine Sandis has been working on Wittgenstein’s approach to other minds for over a decade. This volume collects his best writings on the topic. It sketches a picture of Wittgenstein’s approach to understanding others which explains how his anti-scepticism with regard to the philosophical problem of ‘other minds’ is not only compatible with but also supported by his scepticism concerning the real-life difficulty of understanding others (and vice versa).
While each individual essay focuses on particular issues in Wittgenstein (including philosophical anthropology, interpersonal psychology, communication theory, and animal minds), they collectively paint a picture of what he takes the real problem of other minds to be, how to overcome it, and the limitations of our understanding.
The book not only offers a fresh exegesis of Wittgenstein’s public and private writings on these matters but also proceeds to show the relevance of Wittgenstein beyond the remit of philosophy and the academy as a whole. These include issues in ethology, anthropology, AI intelligibility, psychology, and intercultural studies.
Reviews
‘Few people can have thought as deeply on Wittgenstein’s reflections on ‘other minds’ and on understanding people as Constantine Sandis. His essays exhibit wide knowledge of the confusions of philosophers, psychologists and cognitive neuroscientists, as well as exemplary sensitivity to the complexity, cultural relativity and context dependence of human relations.’—Peter Hacker, St. John’s College, Oxford.
‘A rich and readable collection of essays that is concerned not with the traditional problem of other minds, but with the ordinary obstacles to understanding others, and how we should understand the failures to connect which characterise the human condition. Although Wittgenstein is the dominant influence in the essays, Sandis also draws on a wide range of Wittgenstein interpreters, philosophical, literary and historical sources, which he uses in developing his own distinctive view of what is involved in understanding, and failing to understand, others.’—Marie McGinn, Professor Emerita, University of York
‘Among the many eminent commentators that have shed light on Wittgenstein’s thought, Constantine Sandis stands out by dint of the extraordinary range of his interests and his ability to think and write “outside the box”. The title of this collection nicely captures both this open- mindedness and a unifying theme – namely the challenges involved in trying to understand subjects which are or at least seem to be remote from our own parochial perspective. These subjects range from human individuals and communities through non-human animals – Wittgenstein’s famous “speaking lion” – to works of art and artificial systems. In all of these cases, Sandis sheds invaluable light, in a prose that is both lucid and precise, and often displays a puckish sense of humour. Essential reading for anyone interested in the importance of Wittgenstein’s work in contemporary hermeneutic themes.’ — Professor Hans-Johann Glock, Department of Philosophy, University of Zurich
‘In this collection of essays, Constantine Sandis reminds us that there is a lot more to the philosophical issue of other minds than the sceptical question of their existence. He expertly explores some of Wittgenstein’s fascinating remarks on the difficulties of understanding other people. The essays are lucidly written, well-informed and insightful.’—Severin Schroeder, the University of Reading, UK
‘Constantine Sandis is a leading expert on the philosophy of Wittgenstein and also a serious and original philosopher in his own right. These engaging and persuasive essays address the question of how we can understand those alien to us, be they humans, animals or artworks. An invaluable contribution in an age of conflict and dissent.’—Edward Kanterian, Emeritus Reader in Philosophy, University of Kent, UK
‘Constantine Sandis’s remarkable new book offers a fascinating journey, and a true testament to the transformational power of Wittgenstein’s philosophy. Sophisticated yet accessible, these seductively curious essays scrutinise Wittgenstein’s views on the so-called problem of other minds. It is a truly important book we can all learn from.’—Lambros Malafouris, the University of Oxford, UK
‘In this enthralling collection of essays, Constantine Sandis presents us with a highly original, multifaceted discussion of Wittgenstein’s approach to understanding others. By subtly departing from mainstream themes, Sandis succeeds in illuminating a most urgent, personal and philosophical Wittgensteinian concern: what it is to understand (rather than know) one another.’—Chon Tejedor, Profesora de Filosofía, Universitat de València, Spain
‘With an impressive command of the literature on understanding others, Sandis explores the later Wittgenstein’s enigmatic remarks, providing a multi-layered context in which to appreciate them. From a lion who can talk, to conversations with machines, to the songs of Bob Dylan, this revised compilation of Sandis’s essays presents an excellent contribution to Wittgenstein Studies.’ —Julia Tanney, Independent Researcher
Author Information
Constantine Sandis is Visiting Professor of Philosophy at the University of Hertfordshire and a founding director of Lex Academic.
Series
Anthem Studies in Wittgenstein
Table of Contents
Preface ; Acknowledgments ; Abbreviations of Wittgenstein’s Works ; Introduction: The Mental Lives of Others ; 1 ‘If Some People Looked Like Elephants and Others Like Cats’: Wittgenstein on Understanding Others and Forms of Life ; 2 Making Ourselves Understood: Wittgenstein and Moral Epistemology ; 3 Who Are ‘We’ for Wittgenstein? ; 4 Understanding the Lion for Real ; 5 On Safari with Glock ; 6 Understanding Other Cultures (Without Mind-Reading) ; 7 Period and Place: Wittgenstein and Collingwood on Understanding Others ; 8 One Fell Swoop: Small Red Book Historicism Before and After Davidson ; 9 If an Artwork Could Speak: Aesthetic Understanding After Wittgenstein ; 10 Wittgenstein and Communication Technology: In Conversation with Richard Harper ; References ; Index
Links
Stay Updated
Information
Latest Tweets